Can I Use 5w30 Instead of 5w20 – Clearing All Confusions

Engine oils receive their grades through the measurement of viscosity. In colder climates, 5w20 and 5w30 motor oils find frequent application, though they’re more suitable for less demanding tasks and aging engines. This is because a higher rating signifies a denser consistency, catering well to engines prone to heating. Regarding this, a query that surfaces often is: Can I use 5W30 instead of 5W20

Though it’s usually acceptable to utilize an oil with a viscosity rating slightly above or below the manufacturer’s suggestion, it’s advisable to stick to the viscosity stated in the owner’s manual.

can i use 5w30 instead of 5w20 — *Image credit: Freepik*

Table of Contents

Understanding 5W20 and 5W30 Oil Grading

When it comes to multi-grade oil, the XW-XX format is used for grading, wherein the initial number (e.g., 5) represents winter viscosity, indicating the oil’s thickness at 104°F (40°C), with W signifying winter. The subsequent numbers (20 and 30 in this instance) indicate the oil’s viscosity at 212°F (100°C) when it warms up.

In this scenario, 5w20 and 5w30 engine oils may share matching viscosity ratings, yet their performance at 104°F differs, leading to a crucial distinction. Consequently, as the engine achieves its 5w operating temperature, 30w exhibits greater thickness compared to 5w20.

Can I Use 5W30 Instead Of 5W20?

I previously mentioned that opting for an oil with a viscosity grade one level above or below the manufacturer’s recommendation is acceptable. Nonetheless, adhering to the viscosity stated in the owner’s manual is advisable.

When comparing 5W20 and 5W30 oils, their viscosity is identical at cold engine temperatures. The distinction arises as 5W-20 maintains slightly lower viscosity when the engine is at operating temperature. This attribute enhances fuel efficiency and facilitates swift filling of the engine’s narrow gaps.

Opting for 5W-30 instead might lead to a decrease in fuel efficiency and hinder proper engine circulation. Although employing it as a short-term solution is unlikely to result in enduring damage to your engine, do recall that the engineers who built your engine had a particular viscosity of oil in their intentions; hence, adhering to it is best.

Certain car manufacturers do suggest varying oil thicknesses based on the climate situation. If facing this scenario, we suggest opting for a less viscous oil in colder weather to facilitate smoother cold starts and start-up safety.

In brief, in comparing 5W-20 and 5W-30 oils, their cold viscosity remains identical, but the 5W-30 variant exhibits slightly higher thickness during regular operations.

What occurs if I put 5w30 oil instead of 5w20 oil?

Rapid complications might not arise when employing varied oils for your motor. But lacking this capability elevates the danger to your engine’s lifespan. Subjecting your motor to slightly denser oil than its accustomed counterpart triggers added friction.

Thus, your engine exerts more to fulfill duties against heightened resistance. This surplus friction from the heftier oil potentially retards your internal combustion engine, culminating in seepages, engine sediments, and sediment accumulation.

Can I blend 5w20 and 5w30?

It’s not advisable to blend those. The impact might not show on your motor right away after blending occurs. Yet, thinking about the engine’s overall lifespan, it’s wiser to promptly empty and replace the oil. If using the suggested oil for replacement gets delayed, you can try these steps:

Maintain a reduced driving speed.
Ensure the engine stays as cool as possible.
If the temperature hits the danger zone, halt the vehicle, allow the engine to cool briefly, and restart.
If overheating persists, always choose roadside help.

What’s more effective: 5w20 or 5w30?

In the end, it’s consistently wisest to opt for the engine oil suggested by the manufacturer, as opposed to engaging in trials. This clarifies that 5w20 and 5w30 are neither superior nor inferior, except in cases concerning particular automobiles. The juncture at which individuals occasionally venture differently is within the cold viscosity classification (5w).

In particular, opting for lower cold viscosity in colder weather and a higher viscosity in warmer regions. This approach makes sense for aging vehicles or under very high/low temperatures – a practice endorsed by certain makers. Nevertheless, this situation doesn’t apply here, as 5w20 and 5w30 share identical cold ratings.

Despite this, adhering to the oil type advised by your manufacturer remains the optimal choice. If the owner’s manual doesn’t outline seasonal oil switches, it’s advisable to abstain.

What Are the Best Substitutes to 5w30?

Should you not find 5w30 accessible due to any unforeseen circumstances, there exist preferable options to 5w20—namely, 0w30 and 10w30—owing to their ability to maintain viscosity at operational heat levels. Given that the oil primarily functions within these temperature ranges about 90% of the time, opting for 0w30 or 10w30 ensures alignment with the manufacturer’s stipulated specifications throughout extended durations.

However, between these options, 0w30 proves to be the more favorable selection. The primary reason is the diminishing gap among mobile components over successive car generations, coupled with enhanced engine efficiency. Consequently, during colder temperatures, the viscosity of 10w30 oil might impede seamless circulation through these restricted areas. Admittedly, 0w30 may offer a slightly less substantial protective layer, yet the variance remains minimal.

Nevertheless, regardless of the situation, 0w30 and 10w30 prove superior to 5w20 as another option. Furthermore, you have the option to abide by the guideline for varying climates – for instance, residing in an area with highly frigid conditions, such as Alaska; under those circumstances, lean toward selecting solely 0w30 due to 10w30 likely exhibiting excessive viscosity.

Alternatively, in contrast, 10w30 could prove suitable in regions such as Florida or southern Texas, characterized by consistently elevated temperatures, as these conditions mimic the behavior of 0w30 oil during colder intervals.

Why It Is Not A Good Idea To Put 5W20 Oil In A 5W30 Engine?

The thickness of engine oil plays a crucial role in its performance within the motor. Car oil has a dual role during vehicular operation. It operates as a lubricant, preventing friction and abrasion among the engine’s mobile components. Moreover, it aids in maintaining engine temperature.

Automobile engines run quite hot, and excessive heat can lead to costly consequences. The oil aids in keeping it cooled to the correct temperature, thus ensuring the safety of these components.

Oil viscosity is crucial in this matter—increased consistency results in thicker oil. Certain engines require higher viscosity for optimal performance, whereas using thicker oil in others merely hampers their functionality.

Employing 5W20 oil when your engine demands a higher viscosity of 5W30 can have adverse effects.

Incorrect weight usage can result in substantial mechanical harm. In the following sections, we’ll closely examine the potential outcomes of employing an inappropriate engine oil weight.

Engine oil could leak.

Maintaining the correct viscosity of oil is crucial for effective engine cooling; inappropriate viscosity might hinder this cooling process. This elevated temperature can potentially harm the internal gaskets and seals of the engine. The consequence could involve deformation or fracture of these vital components, leading to eventual oil seepage.

These leaks are indicative of larger underlying issues, and they won’t resolve autonomously. Neglected minor seepage tends to escalate into substantial leakage over time if left unaddressed. In case you observe any fluid emanating from your automobile, it’s advisable to conduct a comprehensive inspection promptly.

You could notice strange sounds.

In the event of oil selection errors, achieving comprehensive lubrication for the engine’s mobile components might be compromised, potentially resulting in the grinding of gears and related elements.

Such auditory indications serve as signs of an underlying issue, and preventing the deterioration of these components is vital, given the substantial financial ramifications associated with consequential engine damage. The situation could escalate to the extent of rendering the engine irreparable.

Devote proper attention to atypical engine sounds, promptly seeking inspection and servicing to avert impending complications.

Your car may sip more fuel.

During increasing fuel costs, fuel usage efficiency becomes a significant factor.

Most drivers avoid driving at overly high speeds, maintain proper tire pressure, and employ various methods to optimize their miles-per-gallon ratio.

Disregarding the appropriate oil viscosity can undo all the advancements made. If the viscosity does not align with your engine’s requirements, it will result in heightened operational exertion for the engine. This increased effort directly correlates with elevated fuel consumption.

It is advisable to consistently utilize the suitable engine oil viscosity specified for your vehicle to achieve the most favorable fuel efficiency. You should also check our guide to cut fuel costs.

You may see a change in the exhaust fume color.

Using the wrong motor oil can accelerate oil contamination, leading to increased production of carbon deposits and a rapid darkening of the oil’s color. This occurrence, coupled with potential oil seepage via gaskets, has the capability to alter the color of the emissions expelled from your vehicle’s exhaust outlet.

The resulting smoke will turn dark, transitioning into a blackish tone, accompanied by heightened density and a perceptible smell of combustion.

Which oil should I choose for my old engine, 5w20 or 5w30?

More mature motors often need oil with increased viscosity, making 5w30 a suitable choice. In aging engines, components undergo wear, causing greater gaps between moving parts, hence demanding a denser oil such as 5w30 or even 5w50.

Final Thoughts

Ultimately, using 5w20 oil in place of 5w30 doesn’t typically lead to significant issues within the initial 20,000 to 30,000 miles. However, it’s essential to be aware that specific engines react differently to oil thickness, so it’s advisable not to tinker. If acquiring 5w30 is problematic, consider 0w30 or 10w30 as alternatives.

These two options exhibit matching viscosity under regular temperatures, producing minimal divergence. Opt for 0w30 over 10w30 for more modern vehicles, perhaps those under 15 years old. Conversely, lean toward the denser 10w30. In frigid climates, omit the 10w30 as well.

Latest Posts: